An external hard drive is a storage device located outside of a computer that is connected through a USB cable or wireless connection (https://www.techopedia.com/definition/2940/external-hard-drive). External hard drives provide additional storage space and allow users to back up files or even entire systems. They can be easily disconnected from a computer when not in use.
It is important not to unplug an external hard drive while it is actively reading or writing data. Doing so can lead to file corruption or loss of data. The system will warn against unplugging an external drive while it is in use. It is best to properly eject or safely remove external drives before disconnecting them physically.
Risk of Data Corruption
When data is being written to or read from the external hard drive, suddenly disconnecting the drive can lead to data corruption. This is because the read/write heads in the hard drive are physically moving to access data on the spinning platters. If power is suddenly cut during this process, the heads may fail to write all the data or read incomplete data, resulting in corruption.
According to experts on Quora, “Sudden power loss can interrupt the file transfer process and cause only parts of a file to be written, leading to corruption.” (Source)
Similarly, a Microsoft forum post notes, “When you power it down or unplug it, you interrupt that communication and it results in corrupted files on the drive.” (Source)
In summary, the sudden disconnection can lead to incomplete read/write operations and file corruption.
Risk of Physical Damage
Suddenly disconnecting or unplugging an external hard drive can potentially cause physical damage to the drive. When the hard drive is in operation, the platters inside are spinning at a high velocity. Abruptly cutting power to the drive by unplugging it can cause the platters to stop spinning immediately, while the read-write heads may still be in motion. This sudden stop can cause the heads to crash or scrape against the platters, physically damaging the surface of the disks.
The impact from this type of event depends on when during the operation the disconnection occurs. If unplugged when the heads are parked in a safe position away from the platters, there may be no damage at all. However, unplugging mid-operation when the heads are moving increases the risk of a crash. Physical damage to platters can destroy data, sometimes rendering a drive completely unusable if the damage is severe enough.1
To avoid this risk, it’s important to properly eject the external hard drive before unplugging it. The eject process will safely park the heads and spin down the platters before power is cut off. Sudden shocks or drops while operating can also damage an external hard drive, so it’s best practice to avoid unplugging drives mid-operation.
Best Practices
When using an external hard drive, it is extremely important to properly eject the drive before physically disconnecting it. Improperly ejecting the drive can lead to data loss and corruption. Here are some tips for safely ejecting an external hard drive:
On Windows, locate the “Safely Remove Hardware” icon in the system tray and click on it. Select your external hard drive from the menu that pops up and wait for the confirmation saying it is safe to remove the hardware. Alternately, you can right-click on the external drive icon and select “Eject”. [1]
On Macs, right-click on the external drive icon on your desktop and select “Eject”. You can also go to Finder > File > Eject. [2]
Avoid unplugging the drive while it is actively reading or writing data. Wait for any file transfers to complete before ejecting. Do not simply unplug the USB cable without properly ejecting first.
Get in the habit of always ejecting external drives before disconnecting them. Make it part of your routine. This will help avoid potential data loss or corruption.
Data Recovery
If accidentally unplugging your external hard drive leads to data corruption or the drive not being detected, data recovery software can help recover lost files and folders in many cases. Some top data recovery software options include:
Disk Drill (https://www.cleverfiles.com/) – Disk Drill has powerful scanning to find lost partitions, recovers 200+ file formats, and has advanced rebuilding of corrupted drives.
Recuva (https://www.ccleaner.com/recuva) – Recuva is a free data recovery tool that can restore files on your hard drive, memory cards, USB drives, and more.
Stellar Data Recovery (https://www.stellarinfo.com/) – Stellar offers capabilities like corrupted partition recovery and encrypted drive file recovery.
If the data corruption is severe, you may need to use a professional data recovery service for specialized techniques like hardware repair and manually extracting data from the platters. However, recovery software should be attempted first before resorting to costly services.
Preventing Future Issues
There are several steps you can take to prevent future issues when disconnecting an external hard drive:
Set the drive to be read-only: In your operating system settings, configure the external drive to be read-only. This will prevent any data from being written to the drive while it is connected, reducing the chance of corruption if it is suddenly disconnected (source).
Back up data regularly: Be sure to back up important data from your external drive on a regular basis. Cloud backup services or simply copying files to another location protects against data loss if the external drive fails or is corrupted (source).
Use a UPS: Connecting your external drive to an uninterruptible power supply (UPS) can keep it safely powered down in the event of a power outage or surge. This helps prevent corruption or damage from sudden disconnects (source).
Software Solutions
There are several software programs that can help reduce the risk of data loss or corruption when accidentally unplugging an external hard drive. These apps sync files between the external drive and your computer’s internal drive in real time, ensuring no changes are lost if the external drive is disconnected.
Some top options include:
-
FreeFileSync – An open source file sync app for Windows, Mac and Linux. It compares source and destination folders and syncs any changes both ways to keep files mirrored. Supports real-time monitoring. (Source)
-
GoodSync – A proprietary sync app with advanced features like versioning. Monitors folders in real-time and syncs bidirectionally. Works across Windows, Mac, servers, and the cloud. (Source)
Using real-time sync software ensures files are continuously backed up between your computer and external drive. If the drive is unplugged accidentally, no changes will be lost. The apps also reduce errors from unsafely removing external drives.
Cloud Storage
As an alternative to using an external hard drive, many people are turning to cloud storage services. According to Cloud Storage vs External Hard Drive: Which Is Best?, cloud storage provides a number of advantages over external hard drives:
- Accessibility – Cloud storage can be accessed from anywhere with an internet connection, while external drives can only be accessed from the device they are plugged into.
- Collaboration – Cloud services make it easy to share and collaborate on files with others.
- Reliability – Files are stored on remote servers with multiple backups, reducing the risk of data loss that can occur with external drives.
- Scalability – Cloud storage can easily be scaled up as your storage needs grow, unlike limited external drive capacity.
Cloud storage may be a good option for those looking for easy access to files across devices, needing to collaborate or share files, or wanting the added data redundancy of remote servers. However, internet connectivity is required to access files in the cloud. External drives may still be preferred for completely offline access or for those with limited internet connectivity.
When Unplugging is OK
There are some scenarios where it is generally safe to disconnect an external hard drive without ejecting it first:
If the computer and drive are both powered off, you can physically disconnect the hard drive. With no power running to the drive or OS, there is no risk of data corruption from an improper disconnection. Just be sure the computer is completely shut down before unplugging the drive.1
On Windows, you can safely remove an external drive when the computer is locked or logged out of your user account. With no user actively accessing files, Windows allows hot-swapping devices in this state. Just don’t disconnect external storage if your account is logged in and active.2
On Macs, you can disconnect an external drive when the computer is in Sleep mode safely. With the machine asleep, macOS is designed to allow hot-plugging devices.1 Just don’t unplug storage while the Mac is powered on and in use.
In general, you should be able to safely disconnect external drives when the computer and OS are fully inactive and not modifying any files. The key is avoiding data transfer or writing when physically unplugging the drive.
Summary
In summary, accidentally unplugging an external hard drive can lead to data corruption or physical damage under certain circumstances. The best practices are to safely eject the drive first, use a UPS to prevent sudden power loss, and utilize software that autosaves and backs up files. If the drive is unplugged when actively reading or writing data, you may need professional data recovery. Going forward, using cloud storage and storage devices designed for portability can help prevent issues. The key points are:
- Safely eject drives before unplugging to avoid corruption
- Use a UPS to prevent damage from power loss
- Leverage auto-save and backup software
- Seek data recovery help if needed after improper unplug
- Choose portable drives designed for frequent unplugging
- Use cloud storage for always-accessible files
By understanding the risks and following best practices, the effects of accidentally unplugging an external drive can be minimized. Just be sure to safely eject external storage devices before disconnecting them.